This Easy Creamy Cheesy Potato Bake is true to its name – easy and creamy and cheesy! Made with cubes of potato which are cooked with the sauce so there’s no need to par boil the potatoes or make the sauce separately. Plus, it’s a whole lot faster to chop potatoes than slice them thinly – and you get more sauce in every bite!
Easy Creamy Cheesy Potato Bake. How’s that for a tongue twister, eh? Try saying that 3 times real fast (even harder, after a couple of glasses of wine).
I keep getting myself confused, and I’ve probably gotten it wrong a few times in this post even though I’ve gone back to check several times!
When you think of potato bakes, you probably think of sliced potatoes. Otherwise known as Potato Gratin, Potato Dauphinoise and Scalloped Potatoes to those in the States. And here’s my recipe (well, Julia Child’s!) for Potato Dauphinoise, if that’s what you’re after. But hear me out on this chunky style before you go running off!
Not only is this easier and faster to put together – i.e. no need to thinly slice mounds of potato then layer them in the baking dish – with this “chunky style” creamy potato bake, you get soft pieces of potato bathed in creamy cheesy sauce. Whereas with potato gratin, the sliced potatoes tends to be packed more closely together so there’s less creamy cheesy goodness with every bite. Some might even say it’s packed too densely for their taste (gasp!).
I wasn’t actually planning to share this recipe. A couple of weeks ago, I had an Easter Taste Testing Lunch at my place, primarily to get feedback on the Salmon Gravlax that I shared last week (resounding success! Almost unanimously Top Pick of the Day). I called upon a group of my mother’s golfing friends who are always willing and able taste testers. Ahhh the luxury of retirement. A leisurely game of golf then a 3 course lunch!
I enjoy these Taste Testing sessions because they bring both years of years of experience and complete honesty to the table. No one holds back providing very constructive feedback, as well as useful suggestions. Suffice to say a number of recipes have never made this blog because of the feedback from this group of Taste Testers! 😂
Anyway, I made this Easy Creamy Cheesy Potato Bake (well, my mother did, under my instruction) because I had so many other things to prepare, I wanted to put something together quickly. And it was a topic of hot discussion that it was an afterthought-side-dish that I really didn’t think was that special but everyone loved it! So I had to share it!
I’m not going to lie to you. This ain’t the healthiest recipe on this blog. It’s basically made up of all things that are the first to go when trying to be “healthy” – potatoes, cream and cheese.
And that, my friends, is why it is so darn good. OK, so it’s not the sort of thing I’d make on for a usual midweek meal. But weekends and feasting occasions? Heck yes! Especially when I want to steal the show. 😉 – Nagi x
Hungry for more? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all of the latest updates.
Easy Creamy Cheesy Potato Bake
Ingredients
- 1.25kg/ 2.5lb potatoes (any, other than waxy potatoes, see Note 1)
- 2/3 cup (160 ml) milk (full or low fat)
- 3/4 cup (185 ml) thickened cream (heavy cream) (heavy cream)
- 1/3 cup mayonnaise , preferably whole egg (or 1/4 cup cream) (Note 2)
- 1 1/2 tsp fresh thyme leaves , plus more for garnish (or 1 tsp dried)
- 2 large garlic cloves , minced
- 3/4 tsp salt
- Black pepper
- 2 cups (200g) shredded cheese , for mixing (Note 3)
- 1 cup (100g) shredded mozzarella cheese (or sub with another cheese, Note 3)
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 180C/350F (all types).
- Peel and cut the potatoes into 1 3/4 cm / 2/3″ cubes. Place in a large bowl.
- Add all remaining ingredients except mozzarella. Mix.
- Pour into a 3 litre / quart baking dish (mine is 22cm / 9″ square x 6 cm / 2.3″ high).
- Cover with foil. Bake 60 minutes, or until potatoes are tender.
- Remove foil, sprinkle over mozzarella cheese. Bake for 25 minutes or until cheese is golden.
- Rest for 5 – 10 minutes before serving, garnished with extra theme leaves if desired.
Recipe Notes:
Nutrition Information:
WATCH HOW TO MAKE IT
Easy Creamy Cheesy Potato Bake recipe video! Maybe have a napkin handy? 😉
LIFE OF DOZER
Snap photo of dish, then swing camera 30 cm / 1 foot to the left and photograph Dozer. Efficiency of motion. 🙌🏼
first time i have made a potatoe bake… it was super easy and very tasty … thanks Nagi… love your recipes
Hi Nagi,
I’m so excited to make this today! Was just thinking what to do with all these potatoes 🙂
Sadly, I don’t have any cream, do you think this recipe would still work with equal amount of milk to substitute the cream?
I love your recipes. You are my go to for recipes – each one I’ve made is tasty, easy and simple <3
Hi Trilbi, unfortunately not – it won’t thicken and cook down like cream here – N x
Hi thanks for fabulous recipe and video. How many people does this serve? I can’t find the Sliding service size bar to reduce quantities. Thanks again…
Hi Nina, thanks for picking that up! This serves 10 🙂 N x
Made it this evening as a side to steak on the Weber! It was brilliant. Greetings from South Africa.
Can this dish be frozen. I am going away for a week (next week) and I am making dishes for my husband
Hi Susan – yes you can – follow the “make ahead” instructions in the notes, simply freeze instead and then thaw before proceeding to reheat 🙂 N x
I LOVE this recipe, I have made this 4 times lready — and I have failed miserably at other potato bakes! I used Carisma potatoes and don’t bother peeling them. Thank you again! P.S. I love your Chicken Enchiladas, have made that twice now
Where did you get your baking dish?
Fantastic! Served with Grilled garlic chicken tenders. My husband loved the flavor and creamy texture. Used Gruyere cheese. Next to your butter chicken recipe in favorites. Did take longer to cook than indicated but worth it.
I enjoyed this last time I made it!
I want to make it again tomorrow but I don’t have any thickened cream, can I substitute it with something else?
Love and cook lots of your recipes, but this is one of the families favourites. I turn it into an all-in-one side dish by using a mix of potatoe, sweet potatoe, zucchini and cauliflower.
YUM!!! Love the sound of this! N x
Hi
Can this be frozen for later on?
Cheers
Hi Lyn, It can but you might find the cheese splits when you thaw & reheat it – N x
This is my new go to potato bake recipe. It is requested by my family for every occasion. Absolutely delicious, thank you for the recipe!
I love hearing this Mel!!
OMG Nagi, this is amazing! Thank you.
I wonder if this recipe works to have a mix of sweet potato and normal.. I can’t seem to nail this recipe, the potato is cut the right size but takes almost twice as long to cook.. I really want it to work so will keep trying!
Hi Angela, sorry you are having issued – what kind of potatoes are you using? N x
I’m in Australia & use the Woolworths brushed potatoes.
Hi Angela, it could be the size dish you’re using, if the potatoes are stacked too deep they take longer to cook – try a shallower/larger dish 🙂
I have made this twice after discovering this delicious recipe. I know I will keep this as a favorite forever. Used smoked cheddar cheese and loved this taste❤️
Oh that makes me so happy to read Vivian! ❤️
Going to make this on Xmas day. I’m sure we’ll love it.
Making Eggs Benedict for breakfast on Xmas.
YUM! Sounds divine Nancy!
Delious i love it
Wahoo, I’m so happy you love it Matilda ☺️
I made this for the first time last night and followed the recipe exactly except for using dried thyme and not peeling my potatoes. Used Yukon Gold potatoes. I have to say, I was skeptical about the mayo but decided to try it as written. It is SO GOOD. Use the mayo if you were thinking of leaving it out! Thanks for the amazing recipe!!
I’m so glad you loved it Courtney!!!
Hi Nagi, I want to try this but I live on my own and don’t want a serve for 10. If I use say 1/3 of your ingredients and bake for maybe 2/3 the time, would that be a fair guess for the lower volume? Thanks, Bill
Hi Bill, the potatoes will still take time to cook, but you’re right, just adjust the servings size and all the ingredients will reduce for you. I’d check after 30-40 minutes or so to gauge how much longer they require – N x
I haven’t baked this yet but I know it’s going to be a winner just my the taste of the garlicky creamy sauce.
I hope you love it Victor!